Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: If you prioritize plush, cushioned comfort and a soft footbed right out of the box, the Reef Fanning is your pick. If you need strong arch support, premium materials, and a more rugged, all-terrain sole, the OluKai Ohana takes the lead. Both are excellent, but your foot type and intended use will determine the winner.
The Reef Fanning is famous for its ‘DiamondTec’ footbed, which is soft, spongy, and molds to your foot over time. It’s like walking on a pillow, with a gentle massaging texture that feels great even after hours of wear. The arch support is moderate, so it suits neutral feet or those who like a softer feel.
On the other hand, the OluKai Ohana uses a ‘Wet Grip Rubber’ footbed with a ‘compression molded EVA midsole’. The footbed is contoured with a noticeable arch cradle that hugs your arch and provides firm support. It’s not as soft as the Reef, but it’s more substantial underfoot, making it ideal for people with flat feet or those who need more stability for long walks.
Reef Fanning: The outsole is rubber with a herringbone pattern, providing good traction on wet surfaces. The straps are synthetic leather with a soft lining, and they attach to the sole with a ‘hidden anchor’ system that is designed to be durable. However, some users report that the footbed can wear down after a year of heavy use, and the straps may stretch slightly over time.
OluKai Ohana: The outsole is also rubber but with a more aggressive tread pattern, perfect for trails and boat decks. The straps are full-grain leather, which is more premium and tends to last longer, though they require a break-in period. The construction is solid, and the footbed holds up well, making the Ohana a better long-term investment if you’re hard on your flip flops.
This is a critical difference. The Reef Fanning has a ‘drop-in’ arch that is low and flexible. It’s decent for everyday wear but may not provide enough support for those with plantar fasciitis or overpronation. The footbed is flat overall with a slight contour.
The OluKai Ohana features a ‘Molded Anatomical Footbed’ with a pronounced arch support and a heel cup that cradles your heel. This design helps distribute pressure evenly and reduces foot fatigue. If you have high arches or need extra support, the Ohana is the clear winner. Conversely, if you prefer a more natural, flat feel, the Fanning might be more comfortable.
Both flip flops have a classic, casual look, but there are nuances. The Reef Fanning comes in a wider array of colors and patterns, and the straps are slightly wider, giving a sportier vibe. It’s a go-to for beach days, pool parties, and casual outings.
The OluKai Ohana has a more refined, minimalist aesthetic with subtle branding. The leather straps look dressier, so you can pair them with shorts or even casual chinos. They’re versatile enough for a beach vacation or a relaxed dinner. If you want a flip flop that transitions from sand to street, the Ohana is more suitable.
Prices fluctuate, but generally, the Reef Fanning is slightly less expensive than the OluKai Ohana. The Fanning offers great value for the price, especially if you prioritize immediate comfort. The Ohana is a premium product with higher quality materials and better support, justifying a higher price for many users. Consider how often you’ll wear them and what features matter most. For a detailed price comparison and current deals, check out our best flip flops buying guide.
Reef Fanning: The synthetic straps dry quickly, and the footbed is water resistant. However, the soft footbed can absorb water if submerged, making it slippery and requiring air drying. It’s best to avoid wearing them in the ocean for extended periods.
OluKai Ohana: The leather straps are treated to resist water, but they will dry slower. The footbed is designed to channel water away, and the rubber outsole provides excellent grip on wet surfaces. They are more suited for water activities, though leather requires occasional conditioning to keep it supple.
Getting the right fit is crucial for comfort and performance. Both brands generally run true to size, but there are subtle differences to consider.
Reef Fanning: The footbed is designed to be slightly wider and roomier, accommodating a variety of foot shapes. If you have wide feet, the Fanning is often a better choice. The straps are adjustable, but they may feel snug initially and loosen with wear. For a relaxed fit, consider going half a size up if you’re between sizes.
OluKai Ohana: The Ohana has a more contoured fit, with a narrower heel and a snug arch. The leather straps will stretch slightly over time, so if you’re between sizes, it’s usually best to size down for a secure fit. However, if you have a high instep, you might need to size up to avoid pressure on the top of your foot. OluKai provides a detailed sizing chart on their website, and many retailers offer free exchanges, so take advantage of that if unsure.
Remember that flip flops should fit with your heel centered on the footbed and a small amount of space (about a quarter inch) at the front and back. Your toes should not hang off the edge, and the arch should align with your foot’s arch. If you have orthotics, check if the footbed is removable; neither of these models has removable footbeds, so they may not be compatible with custom inserts.
Even with research, buyers often make mistakes that lead to discomfort or wasted money. Here are key pitfalls to avoid when choosing between the Reef Fanning and OluKai Ohana.
1. Prioritizing style over support: Flip flops are not all created equal. If you plan to walk long distances or stand for hours, arch support is critical. The Ohana excels here, while the Fanning is better for short, casual wear. Don’t choose based solely on looks.
2. Ignoring break-in periods: Leather straps, like those on the Ohana, require a break-in period. Expect some initial stiffness. Synthetic straps on the Fanning are softer out of the box but may stretch over time. Plan accordingly.
3. Wearing them for inappropriate activities: Neither flip flop is designed for hiking, running, or heavy sports. They lack the secure fit and protection of dedicated footwear. Use them for casual walking, beach, and light outdoor activities.
4. Not considering maintenance: Leather requires conditioning to prevent cracking, while synthetic materials are easier to clean but may harbor odors. Factor in the upkeep each pair demands.
5. Buying the wrong size: As mentioned, sizing can vary. Always try before you buy or purchase from a retailer with a good return policy. A poor fit can lead to blisters, foot pain, and wasted money.
While the Reef Fanning and OluKai Ohana are excellent for many situations, they aren’t the best for everyone. Here are scenarios where you might want to consider alternatives.
If you need maximum arch support for severe plantar fasciitis: Look for flip flops with even firmer arch support and deeper heel cups, such as those from Vionic or Orthaheel. These brands are designed with podiatrist input and offer more rigid support.
If you’re on a tight budget: Both models are mid-range to premium. If you need a very affordable option, consider brands like Havaianas or Crocs, which offer basic comfort at a lower price point, though with less support and durability.
If you need a water-specific shoe: For frequent water activities, a dedicated water shoe or a flip flop with a more secure fit, like those from Chaco or Teva, might be better. They offer straps that lock your foot in place and dry quickly.
If you have very wide feet: The Reef Fanning is accommodating, but if you need extra width, brands like Birkenstock or Crocs offer wider fits. OluKai also has some wider models, but the Ohana runs narrower.
If you want a dressier look: For a more upscale appearance, consider leather sandals from brands like Clarks or Ecco. They offer a more polished style that can transition to business casual settings.
Ultimately, the best flip flop depends on your individual needs. Assess your foot type, typical usage, and budget before deciding. The Reef Fanning and OluKai Ohana are both top contenders, but they serve slightly different purposes.
The OluKai Ohana is better for flat feet because of its pronounced arch support and heel cradle, which help stabilize the foot and reduce strain. The Reef Fanning is flatter and may not offer enough support.
Yes, both can handle long walks, but the OluKai Ohana is more supportive and durable, making it a better choice for extended walking or hiking on uneven terrain. The Reef Fanning is comfortable for city walks but may cause fatigue after many miles due to less arch support.
If you want easy maintenance and quick drying, go with the Reef Fanning’s synthetic straps. If you prefer a premium look and are willing to care for leather, the OluKai Ohana’s straps are more elegant and durable, but they require occasional cleaning and conditioning.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.