★ Independently researched & tier-ranked — no paid placements · Updated September 2026
HomeClothing & ShoesHow to Break in Reef Fanning Flip Flops: A Step-by-Step Guide
Clothing & Shoes

How to Break in Reef Fanning Flip Flops: A Step-by-Step Guide

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.

The short answer: To break in Reef Fanning flip flops, start by wearing them in short sessions indoors, use a blow dryer on low heat to soften the straps, and consider using a leather conditioner on the footbed. With consistent wear, they should mold to your feet within a week or two.

Why Reef Fanning Flip Flops Need Breaking In

Reef Fanning flip flops are known for their comfort and durability, but like many quality sandals, they can feel stiff initially. The leather or synthetic straps and the contoured footbed need time to soften and shape to your feet. Breaking them in properly prevents blisters and ensures long-term comfort. While some shoes are ‘wear and go,’ the Fanning model benefits from a gradual breaking-in process.

Step-by-Step Breaking In Process

Start Indoors

Begin by wearing your Reef Fannings around the house for short periods, such as 30 minutes to an hour. This allows the materials to warm up and start molding without putting too much pressure on your feet. Walking on carpet or rugs can help cushion the break-in.

Use Heat to Soften Straps

If the straps feel tight or rub against your skin, use a hairdryer on a low heat setting. Hold it about 6 inches away from the straps for 30 seconds, moving back and forth. This softens the material, making it more pliable. Be careful not to overheat, as this can damage the straps. Alternatively, you can use a damp cloth and apply gentle heat.

Stretch with Socks

Wear thick socks with your flip flops for a few hours at home. The socks add bulk, helping to stretch the straps and footbed. This is especially useful if the straps are too tight. After a couple of sessions, remove the socks and try them barefoot to see the difference.

Condition the Leather

If your Reef Fannings have a leather footbed, apply a small amount of leather conditioner (like Lexol or mink oil) to a soft cloth and rub it into the footbed. This will soften the leather and speed up the molding process. Wait for it to dry before wearing.

Tips for Comfortable Wear During Break-In

  • Alternate with other shoes: Don’t wear your Fannings all day at first. Give your feet a break to avoid irritation.
  • Use band-aids or moleskin: Apply them to areas prone to blistering, like the tops of your feet or between toes.
  • Bend and flex the soles: Gently twist and flex the flip flops with your hands to loosen the sole’s stiffness.
  • Wear them in water: If you’re near a pool or beach, getting them wet can help them mold faster, but avoid salt water repeatedly as it can damage materials.

How Long Does It Take?

Typically, it takes 1 to 2 weeks of regular wear to fully break in Reef Fanning flip flops. If you follow the stretching techniques and wear them daily, the process can be faster. Be patient: the more you wear them, the more they conform to your feet.

How to Get the Right Fit and Size

Getting the correct size is crucial for a smooth break-in and long-term comfort. Reef Fanning flip flops generally run true to size, but fit can vary depending on the width of your feet and the shape of your arch. Here is what to consider:

  • Length: Your heel should sit comfortably in the heel cup, with a small amount of space (about a quarter inch) between your longest toe and the front edge. If your toes hang over, the straps will put pressure on the wrong spots and cause blisters.
  • Width: The straps should feel snug but not tight. You should be able to slide a finger under the strap without forcing it. If the straps dig into your skin, the sandals are too narrow or the straps are too tight.
  • Arch support: Reef Fannings have a contoured footbed with arch support. Your arch should rest comfortably on the footbed without feeling like it is being pushed too high. If the arch feels aggressive, it may soften with wear, but if it causes pain, consider a different model.
  • Between sizes? If you are between sizes, sizing up is often better for flip flops because it prevents your toes from hitting the front and reduces strap pressure. However, if the sandal feels too loose, you may need to size down.

Keep in mind that leather straps will stretch slightly with wear, while synthetic straps may stretch less. If you have wide feet, look for models with adjustable straps or consider a wider fit if available.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Breaking In Reef Fannings

Breaking in new sandals can go wrong if you rush it or use the wrong techniques. Avoid these common mistakes to keep your feet happy and your sandals in good shape:

  • Wearing them for too long too soon: Jumping straight into a full day of wear is the quickest way to get blisters. Start with short sessions and gradually increase the time.
  • Using high heat: A hair dryer on high heat can melt adhesives, warp the straps, or damage the footbed. Always use the lowest heat setting and keep the dryer moving.
  • Soaking them completely: While a little water can help mold the footbed, soaking them can weaken the glue and cause the layers to separate. Avoid wearing them in the ocean or pool for extended periods during break-in.
  • Ignoring pain: If you feel sharp pain or persistent rubbing, stop. Pain is a sign that the fit is wrong or the sandals need more gradual break-in. Pushing through can lead to injuries.
  • Using the wrong conditioner: Not all leather conditioners are suitable for all materials. Check the care instructions for your specific model. Using a heavy conditioner on synthetic materials can attract dirt and cause deterioration.
  • Not adjusting straps: Some Reef models have adjustable straps. Make sure they are properly adjusted before and during break-in to avoid uneven pressure.

How to Maintain Your Reef Fannings After Break-In

Once your Reef Fannings are broken in, proper maintenance will keep them comfortable and extend their life. Here are some practical tips:

  • Clean regularly: Wipe the footbed and straps with a damp cloth to remove dirt and sweat. For leather footbeds, use a leather cleaner and conditioner every few months to keep the material supple.
  • Avoid prolonged sun exposure: Leaving them in direct sunlight for long periods can dry out the leather and cause cracking. Store them in a cool, dry place.
  • Rotate your footwear: Giving your sandals a day off between wears allows them to dry out and helps them maintain their shape.
  • Check for wear: Inspect the straps, footbed, and sole for signs of wear. Replace them if the sole is worn through or the straps are fraying, as this can affect comfort and support.
  • Handle with care: Avoid machine washing or drying, as this can damage the materials and adhesives.

When to Consider Alternatives

If after two weeks of consistent wear the flip flops still cause pain or blisters, they might not be the right fit for your foot shape. Consider checking the size, arch support, and strap placement. You might need to size up or down. Also, note that some foot types find certain sandals more comfortable than others. For a broader selection of comfortable flip flops, check out our best flip flops buying guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I speed up the breaking in process?

Yes, using heat and stretching with socks can accelerate the process. Also, wearing them for increasing lengths each day helps.

Will breaking in Reef Fanning affect their warranty?

Reef’s warranty covers manufacturing defects, not normal wear and tear. Breaking in shoes is normal, so it won’t void your warranty as long as you don’t damage them intentionally.

What if I get blisters despite following these steps?

Stop wearing them for a day or two, let your feet heal, then resume gradually. You can also apply mole skin or blister bandaids to protect affected areas.

How we rank

We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.

Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.

Research-based comparison
Manufacturer specs & owner feedback
One transparent S–C rubric
Independently researched, no paid placements

Keep readingContinue the research

Update log

  • - Editorial and on-page review.
  • - Guide first published.