Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: Focus on grip strength, mat size, material compatibility, and adhesive longevity. Choose light grip for paper, standard for most materials, and strong grip for heavy fabrics.
Grip strength determines which materials your mat can hold. Light grip mats work best for delicate papers, cardstock, and vinyl. They leave less residue and are easier to clean. Standard grip mats are the most versatile, suitable for medium weight materials like adhesive vinyl, iron on, and light chipboard. Strong grip mats handle heavy fabrics, thick chipboard, and leather. They have a stronger adhesive but can be harder to remove items from. Consider your typical projects. If you mainly cut paper, stick with light grip. If you do mixed media, standard grip is a safe bet. Strong grip is only necessary for heavy materials.
Most Cricut machines use 12×12 mats for standard projects. The 12×24 mats are great for larger designs or multiple cuts in one go, but they require a machine that supports them (like the Maker or Explore Air 2). Smaller mats (like 6×12 or 9×12) exist for Cricut Joy or specific tasks. Choose the size that fits your machine and project needs. If you often make large signs or long decals, the 12×24 is worth it. For small projects, 12×12 is sufficient and easier to store.
Not all mats work with all Cricut machines. The Cricut Joy uses its own line of small mats. The Maker and Explore series use standard 12×12 or 12×24 mats. Some third party mats may not fit perfectly or may have different adhesive properties. Always check compatibility with your machine model. Also consider the material you cut most. For example, fabric requires a strong grip mat, while delicate paper needs light grip. Using the wrong grip can lead to shifting, tearing, or poor cuts.
Mats lose stickiness over time. Light grip mats last about 20-40 uses if cleaned with a lint roller or mild soap. Standard and strong grip mats can last 30-50 uses depending on material residue. Some mats are marketed as “extra sticky” or “long lasting” but may leave more residue. You can extend mat life by cleaning regularly and using a scraper tool to smooth material. If you cut vinyl frequently, consider a mat with a repositionable adhesive that holds well but releases cleanly. Third party mats often have different adhesive formulas; read reviews to see how long they stay tacky.
Cricut brand mats are reliable, fit perfectly, and have consistent adhesive quality. They cost $10 to $20 each. Third party mats can be cheaper ($5 to $12) but vary in quality. Some work well, others may not hold as well or may leave residue. If you want predictability, stick with Cricut. If you want to save money, research third party options with good reviews. For a detailed comparison of top rated mats, see our Which Cricut Mat Is Best for Your Projects? guide. It breaks down the best picks for different needs and budgets.
Can I use a Cricut mat with other cutting machines? Yes, many Silhouette and other machines can use Cricut mats, but you may need an adapter or may have to trim the mat to fit. Check your machine’s specifications first.
How do I restore stickiness to my mat? Clean it with a lint roller or wash with mild soap and water. Avoid alcohol or harsh chemicals as they can damage the adhesive. If it’s still not sticky, consider a new mat.
Should I buy a mat with a grid or without? Grids help with alignment and measuring. Most Cricut mats have a grid, which is useful for precise placement. Some third party mats lack grids; avoid those if you need accuracy.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.