Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: Tub stoppers are designed to seal the drain completely for water retention, ideal for baths. Drain covers are meant to catch debris while allowing water to flow, perfect for showers. Your choice depends on your primary use: bathing or showering.
Tub stoppers are devices that fit into your bathtub drain to create a watertight seal, preventing water from escaping. They come in various styles: flat rubber stoppers that press into the drain, push-pull stoppers that pop up and down, and toe-touch stoppers that you press with your foot. Their main job is to hold water in the tub so you can enjoy a relaxing soak. They are not meant to allow water to flow through while in place.
Drain covers, also known as strainers or hair catchers, sit on top of the drain opening. They are designed to let water pass through while trapping hair, soap scum, and other debris, preventing clogs. They are commonly used in showers, but can also be used in tubs when you want to keep the drain open for quick rinsing or while the tub is not in use. They do not seal the drain; they only filter.
The fundamental difference is function: a stopper seals, a cover strains. This means they are not interchangeable for the same tasks. If you try to use a drain cover to fill a tub, water will simply flow out. If you use a stopper in a shower, it will cause water to pool around your feet. The design reflects this: stoppers have a solid surface or a rubber seal, while covers have holes or grids. Some modern products, like a push-pull stopper with a built-in strainer, combine both functions, but they are not the norm.
Your choice hinges on your primary tub use. If you take baths regularly, you need a tub stopper. For showering, a drain cover is essential to prevent clogs. Many households use both: a stopper for bathing, and a cover for showering or between baths to catch hair. If you have a tub-shower combo, consider a stopper that can also function as a strainer when open, or keep a cover handy for shower days. For more guidance on selecting the right stopper for your bathtub, check out our best tub stopper buying guide.
Getting the right fit is the most common frustration with both tub stoppers and drain covers. A stopper that is too small will not seal, and a cover that is too large may not sit flush. To measure, first remove any existing stopper or cover. Then use a tape measure or ruler to find the inside diameter of the drain opening. Most bathtub drains are either 1.5 inches or 2 inches in diameter, but some older tubs may have unusual sizes. Also note the type of drain: some have a threaded center post, while others are smooth. Push-pull and toe-touch stoppers often replace the entire drain assembly, so you may need to unscrew the old one and match the thread size. For drop-in rubber stoppers, the outside diameter of the rubber part should be slightly larger than the drain opening to create a snug seal. If you are unsure, take a photo of your drain with a ruler next to it to a hardware store, or consult a plumber. Many manufacturers list compatibility charts, so check the product specifications before buying. A properly fitted stopper should sit flat and require only light pressure to seal.
Both tub stoppers and drain covers need regular cleaning to function well and last. For stoppers, hair and soap scum can accumulate on the sealing surface, preventing a tight seal. After each bath, rinse the stopper and wipe it with a soft cloth. Once a week, remove the stopper and clean the drain opening with a brush and mild cleaner. For rubber stoppers, avoid harsh chemicals that can degrade the rubber; a mixture of baking soda and vinegar works well. For drain covers, remove trapped hair after every shower or at least every few days. Most covers lift out easily, but some are screwed in place. Soak metal or plastic covers in warm soapy water to remove soap scum, then scrub with an old toothbrush. If you have a combined stopper-strainer, disassemble it according to the manufacturer’s instructions and clean all parts. Also check for wear: rubber seals can crack over time, and plastic parts can become brittle. Replace any damaged components promptly to avoid leaks or clogs. Regular maintenance not only keeps your drain flowing but also extends the life of your plumbing.
Many people run into problems because they choose the wrong product or install it incorrectly. Here are mistakes to avoid. First, do not use a drain cover as a stopper. It will not hold water, and you may end up with a slow drain and a frustrating bath. Second, do not force a stopper that does not fit. If it requires excessive pressure to seal, it may damage the drain or leak anyway. Third, do not ignore the drain type. A push-pull stopper will not work in a drain that requires a lift-and-turn mechanism. Fourth, do not skip cleaning. A clogged strainer can cause water to back up, and a dirty stopper may not seal. Fifth, do not overtighten plastic or metal parts when installing; this can strip threads or crack the drain. Finally, do not assume all tubs are standard. Measure before you buy, and read owner reviews to see if a product fits common drain sizes. By avoiding these mistakes, you will save time and avoid unnecessary returns.
Sometimes neither a standard tub stopper nor a drain cover is the best solution. If you have a very old or unusual drain, you may need a custom-fitted stopper or a universal rubber plug that can be trimmed to size. For showers, a mesh screen or a silicone hair catcher that sits over the drain can be a good alternative to a rigid cover, especially if you have a tile shower floor. If you are dealing with frequent clogs, a drain snake or enzyme cleaner might be necessary in addition to a cover. When should you not buy either? If your drain is already damaged or has a broken seal, a new stopper or cover will not fix the underlying issue; you may need a plumber to replace the drain assembly. Also, if you rent and cannot modify the drain, a simple rubber stopper or a removable cover is your best bet. And if you never take baths, you may not need a stopper at all; a drain cover alone will suffice. Assess your habits and plumbing before making a purchase.
No, drain covers are not designed to create a watertight seal. They will allow water to flow through, so you cannot use them to fill a tub for a bath.
Check your drain size and type. Common types include push-pull, flip-it, toe-touch, and lift-and-turn. Measure your drain diameter and choose a stopper that matches. If unsure, consult a plumber or refer to our buying guide for details.
Yes, some stoppers have a built-in strainer or a design that allows water to flow when the stopper is in the open position. These are ideal for tub-shower combos, but always verify that they seal properly for bathing.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.