Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: For hiking, a wide-brim UPF hat is almost always the better choice. It provides reliable, rated sun protection (UPF 50+), dries quickly, resists crushing, and holds up to sweat and rain. Straw hats are stylish and breathable for casual use but lack serious sun protection, become floppy when wet, and can be damaged easily on the trail. If you plan to hike regularly, choose a wide-brim UPF hat. Choose straw only for short, low-intensity walks in shaded areas.
When you’re hiking, you’re exposed to UV rays directly and indirectly. Even on cloudy days, up to 80% of UV passes through clouds. A hat with a UPF rating (Ultraviolet Protection Factor) indicates how much UV radiation it blocks. A UPF 50+ hat blocks about 98% of UV rays. Straw hats, unless specifically treated and labeled, often have no UPF rating because the natural weave lets UV through. Many straw hats have wide brims, but the material and weave determine protection. You can’t trust a hat’s look; you need a certified rating.
Straw hats are naturally breathable and ventilated, making them feel cooler on a hot day. However, they absorb sweat and become heavy and soggy. They also lose shape when wet. Wide-brim UPF hats are often made of nylon, polyester, or Supplex with mesh panels. They wick sweat away, dry quickly, and have adjustable drawstrings or fit systems. Some have moisture-wicking sweatbands inside. For a strenuous hike, you want a hat that manages moisture, not one that turns into a wet sponge.
Straw hats are fragile. They crush, bend, and tear against branches. They are not packable; you have to carry them or wear them. Wide-brim UPF hats are crushable and packable. Many fold into a pocket or stuff sack. They are water-resistant, quick-drying, and can handle being thrown in a backpack. They also retain their shape after being crushed. If you’re hiking through thick brush or scrambling, a UPF hat will survive. A straw hat will not.
Wide-brim UPF hats come with useful features: chin straps to keep your hat on in wind, neck capes for extra neck protection, and packable designs. Many have rollable brims that can be shaped for better vision. Straw hats typically lack these features. Some have a simple chin strap, but you can’t adjust the brim or add a cape. For hiking, you need a hat that stays put and offers coverage for your ears and neck. UPF hats are designed for that.
If you’re taking a short, easy walk on a shaded trail or a picnic, a straw hat can be fine. But you need to apply sunscreen to your ears, neck, and face because the straw offers limited coverage. Also, check if the straw hat has a UPF rating. Some treated straw hats exist, but they are rare. If you do use straw, avoid wearing it in the rain or near water. Once wet, it loses shape and becomes heavy. For any serious hiking, invest in a proper UPF hat. If you want to compare specific models, check out this buying guide for sun hats.
Not reliably. Straw hats typically block less UV than a UPF-rated fabric hat. The loose weave and thin material allow UV rays to pass through. Even with a wide brim, you may get sunburn through the hat itself. If you want guaranteed protection, choose a hat labeled UPF 50+.
You can add a dark lining or treat it with UV-protective spray, but these methods are not foolproof and may wash off. It’s better to buy a hat specifically designed and tested for sun protection.
A brim of at least 3 inches provides good coverage for your face and ears. A neck cape adds extra protection for the back of your neck. Look for a UPF hat with a wide, stiff brim and a chin strap for windy conditions.
In summary, for hiking, choose a wide-brim UPF hat. It is safer, more durable, and more comfortable over long distances. Reserve straw hats for casual, low-risk outdoor activities. Your skin will thank you.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.