Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: The Regalo Easy Step Extra Tall is generally better for large dogs and wider openings, offering a 38-inch height and pressure-mount flexibility, while the Evenflo Walk Thru Gate is better for standard doorways, featuring a 30-inch height and a walk-through door that swings both ways. Choose Regalo if you need extra height and width; choose Evenflo for convenience and a more compact footprint.
When you’re separating spaces, the first thing to consider is how tall and wide the gate needs to be. The Regalo Easy Step Extra Tall stands at 38 inches tall, which is a significant advantage for containing taller dogs or for parents who want extra security. It also expands to fit openings between 29 and 48 inches wide, making it versatile for doorways, hallways, and even wider entries like the bottom of stairs. In contrast, the Evenflo Walk Thru Gate is 30 inches tall, which is standard for baby gates but may be too low for a determined large dog to jump. It fits openings from 29 to 42 inches, so it’s slightly less flexible for very wide spaces. If you have a large breed or a wide opening, the Regalo is the clear winner.
Another key difference is how each gate mounts. The Regalo Easy Step Extra Tall uses a pressure-mount system, which means it installs without drilling or screwing into your walls. Rubber pads on both sides press against the doorframe or wall, holding the gate in place. This is great for renters or those who don’t want to leave permanent marks. However, pressure mounts are not as sturdy as hardware mounts, especially if pushed hard by a large dog. The Evenflo Walk Thru Gate can be used with either pressure mount or hardware mount, giving you the option to screw it into the wall for extra stability. If you have a very active pet or a toddler who likes to climb, hardware mounting is safer. So, Evenflo offers more flexibility, but Regalo is simpler if you’re looking for a quick, no-drill setup.
If you’re going to be passing through the gate frequently, the door mechanism is crucial. The Evenflo Walk Thru Gate features a walk-through door that opens in both directions, which is super convenient when your hands are full. The door swings shut automatically, and the latch is easy to operate with one hand. The Regalo Easy Step Extra Tall also has a walk-through door, but it only swings in one direction (you can choose which way). This is a minor inconvenience if you’re moving between rooms often. However, the Regalo’s door is wider, which might be better for carrying large items or for pets that need a bit more room. For pure convenience, Evenflo takes the edge.
Both gates are JPMA certified and meet safety standards, but there are differences in locking mechanisms. The Regalo uses a metal twist lock that is easy for adults but tough for kids and pets to figure out. The Evenflo uses a similar twist lock, but it also has a dual-locking system that requires two steps to open, which is even more childproof. In terms of durability, both are made of sturdy metal and plastic, but the Regalo’s taller frame feels more substantial. However, the Evenflo’s hardware-mount option adds extra security if you’re worried about the gate being knocked over. For high-traffic homes, both hold up well, but if you have a strong dog that likes to lean on the gate, the Evenflo with hardware mount is the safer bet.
Your choice also depends on whether you’re primarily containing pets or kids. For pets, especially large or agile dogs, the Regalo’s extra height is a major advantage. The 38-inch height is harder to jump over, and the wider width means it can fit in more locations, such as room dividers in open floor plans. The Evenflo’s 30-inch height might be okay for small to medium dogs, but it’s not ideal for jumpers. For kids, the Evenflo is a classic choice, with its dual lock and both-way swing door, which is helpful when you’re carrying a baby. The Regalo also works for kids, but the one-way door can be a bit awkward. Consider your primary use: if it’s pets, go Regalo; if it’s kids, Evenflo is a tried-and-true option.
Installation is straightforward for both, but there are nuances. The Regalo requires no tools: you just extend the gate to fit the opening, twist the knobs to tighten, and you’re done. It’s also easy to remove and relocate, making it great for temporary barriers. The Evenflo, if used as a pressure gate, is also tool-free, but if you choose hardware mount, you’ll need a screwdriver and drill. That said, hardware mount gives a permanent feel. If you move the gate frequently, the Regalo is more portable. But if you want a gate that stays put, the Evenflo with hardware is better. Also, both gates come with extensions for wider openings, but the Regalo’s extension kit (sold separately) can expand it up to 96 inches, which is a huge range.
Q: Can I use the Regalo Easy Step Extra Tall for a large dog?
A: Yes, the 38-inch height is ideal for most large dogs, but for very tall or athletic dogs, you might need a taller gate. Always measure your dog’s jumping ability.
Q: Is the Evenflo Walk Thru Gate safe for toddlers?
A: Absolutely. It has a dual-lock mechanism that requires two steps to open, making it one of the more secure gates on the market. It’s also JPMA certified.
Q: Which gate is easier to install?
A: The Regalo is slightly easier because it’s always pressure-mounted with no hardware option. The Evenflo is also easy if you stick with pressure mounting, but it offers a hardware option if you need extra stability.
If you’re still not sure, check out our best pet gates guide for more comparisons and top picks.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.