Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: Both iPlay and Sunday Afternoons offer excellent UPF 50+ sun protection, but they cater to different needs. If you prioritize a budget-friendly, lightweight, and easy-to-pack hat for everyday outings, go with iPlay. If you need a more structured, secure fit with a chin strap that truly stays put, especially for windy days or active babies, Sunday Afternoons is the better choice. Ultimately, the best hat is the one that stays on your baby’s head and covers their face, neck, and ears.
When comparing these two hats, the first thing to examine is the actual coverage area. Both offer UPF 50+ fabric, which blocks about 98% of UV rays. But the design determines how well that protection works in practice.
The iPlay hat has a wide brim that extends around the entire head, offering solid shade for the face, ears, and the back of the neck. The brim is soft and flexible, so it flops down a bit, which can be great for shielding the eyes from low-angle sun. However, because it’s floppy, it may not hold its shape on very windy days, and the back neck coverage might not be as stiff as some parents prefer.
Sunday Afternoons hats, on the other hand, are engineered for serious sun defense. The brim is also wide, but it’s often more structured, with a wire in the front brim that allows you to shape it. This means you can tilt the brim up out of your baby’s eyes or create a downward visor effect. More importantly, many Sunday Afternoons styles include a longer cape or fabric that drapes down the back of the neck, offering additional protection for the nape, which is a common spot for sunburn in babies.
A sun hat only works if it stays on. Here’s how the two compare in terms of fit and comfort.
The iPlay hat is designed with a soft, cotton-like inner sweatband and an adjustable drawstring that cinches under the chin. The chin strap is a simple cord, and while it does hold the hat in place, it can sometimes be too long or not tighten enough for very active babies. There’s also a toggle to adjust the size, but it can slip over time. The hat itself is very lightweight and breathable, making it comfortable for warm days, but the lack of a stiff brim means it can be pushed up or down easily.
Sunday Afternoons hats typically feature a more secure closure system. Many models have a chin strap that uses a breakaway buckle for safety (so it won’t choke if caught) and an adjustable strap in the back that ensures a snug fit. The hats are also designed with a higher crown, which allows for better airflow and reduces the risk of overheating. The fit feels more substantial, and the hat is less likely to be pulled off by a curious toddler.
Babies are tough on their gear, so durability matters. The iPlay hat is made from a soft, 100% polyester fabric that is water-resistant and quick-drying. It’s also machine washable, which is a huge plus for parents dealing with spit-up or food stains. However, over time, the fabric can pill and the brim may lose its shape after repeated washings.
Sunday Afternoons uses higher-end materials, often a nylon or polyester blend that is not only UPF 50+ but also designed to withstand rough handling. The stitching is reinforced, and the fabric is more resistant to tears and abrasion. Many models are also packable, meaning you can stuff them into a diaper bag without worrying about permanent creases. The build quality is noticeably better, which justifies the higher price for many parents.
Style is subjective, but both brands offer a variety of colors and patterns. The iPlay hat has a classic, simple design that appeals to many parents who prefer a minimalist look. It’s available in solid colors and a few cute prints. Sizing is straightforward: typically one size fits most babies from 6 to 24 months, but the adjustable chin strap and drawstring help customize the fit.
Sunday Afternoons offers a wider range of styles, including bucket hats, legionnaire-style hats (with a longer neck flap), and hats with detachable capes. They also have multiple sizes (small, medium, large) to better match your baby’s age and head circumference. This ensures a more precise fit, which is crucial for safety and comfort. If you have a baby with a smaller or larger than average head, the size options are a big advantage.
Price is often a deciding factor. The iPlay UPF 50+ hat is generally budget-friendly, often retailing for under $15. It’s a great value if you need a basic, functional hat for occasional use or as a backup. You can buy two or three for the price of one Sunday Afternoons hat.
Sunday Afternoons hats are more expensive, typically ranging from $25 to $40 depending on the model. But you’re paying for superior construction, better fit options, and a brand that specializes in sun protection. The durability means you might not have to replace it as often, making it a better long-term investment, especially if you have multiple children.
Yes, both brands offer hats that fit newborns, but you need to check the sizing. iPlay’s one-size-fits-most may be too loose for a newborn. Sunday Afternoons offers a ‘newborn’ size that is specifically designed for tiny heads, with a snug fit and a soft chin strap that won’t irritate delicate skin.
Both hats can get wet, but the iPlay dries faster and is more lightweight, making it a good choice for water play. Sunday Afternoons hats are also water-resistant, but some models have a thicker fabric that may take longer to dry. Check the care label for specific instructions.
The iPlay hat has a floppy brim that can cover the back of the neck, but it’s not as secure as the longer neck flap on many Sunday Afternoons styles. If you’re spending a lot of time outdoors, especially in sunny climates, the extra neck coverage of Sunday Afternoons is a significant advantage.
When you’re ready to make a choice, you might also want to check out our comprehensive best baby hat guide for more options and tips. In the end, both iPlay and Sunday Afternoons are trustworthy brands, but your decision should hinge on your budget, your baby’s activity level, and how much sun exposure you anticipate. For a reliable, budget-friendly option, iPlay is a solid pick. For maximum protection and a hat that stays put, Sunday Afternoons is worth the splurge.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.