Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: If you prioritize a softer, roomier fit and eco-friendly materials, choose the Hanes EcoSmart. If you need a more durable, true-to-size hoodie with a classic athletic feel, the Gildan is your best bet. Both offer excellent value, but your choice depends on your personal fit and fabric preferences.
Comfort is king when picking a hoodie. Both Hanes EcoSmart and Gildan use a cotton/polyester blend, but they feel different. The Hanes EcoSmart is made with a 50% cotton, 50% polyester fleece that is brushed for softness. It feels plush against the skin, almost like a worn-in favorite from day one. The fabric is slightly thicker, which adds warmth without being overly heavy.
Gildan’s classic hoodie (like the 18500) uses a 50% cotton, 50% polyester blend as well, but the texture is more utilitarian. It’s not as soft initially, but it breaks in over time. Some users find Gildan’s fabric to be a bit stiffer and less cozy, but it’s still comfortable for everyday wear. If you’re lounging at home or want a blanket-like feel, the EcoSmart wins. For an active lifestyle where moisture wicking matters (though neither is high-tech), Gildan’s tighter knit might feel less clingy.
Both hoodies are budget-friendly, but durability varies. Gildan is known for its robust construction: double-needle stitching at the seams, reinforced cuffs and hem, and a sturdy hood. It holds up well to frequent washing and wear, making it a top choice for screen printers or those who need a workhorse hoodie. The fabric resists pilling better than the EcoSmart.
Hanes EcoSmart, while well-made, uses a softer fleece that may pill or fade slightly faster after repeated washes. The stitching is solid, but the fabric is less dense, so it might not withstand heavy abuse as well. If you’re buying a hoodie to last through years of rugged use, Gildan edges ahead. But for casual wear and comfort, the EcoSmart’s softness might be worth a slight sacrifice in durability.
Fit is where these two diverge significantly. Hanes EcoSmart has a roomier, more relaxed fit. It’s generous in the body and sleeves, perfect for layering or for those who prefer a looser silhouette. The sizes run true to standard, but the cut feels larger than a typical athletic fit. If you’re between sizes, you might consider sizing down for a more tailored look.
Gildan offers a classic, unisex fit that is more true to size. It has a slightly slimmer cut through the torso and arms, but still allows easy movement. It’s not as boxy as the EcoSmart. For a more athletic or fitted appearance, Gildan is the go-to. However, if you like to wear a hoodie over a thick shirt or want extra room, the EcoSmart’s relaxed fit is more forgiving.
Style is subjective, but both brands offer a range of colors. Hanes EcoSmart comes in a variety of muted and earthy tones, with a smooth, matte finish. The fabric has a slightly brushed look that feels modern and cozy. Gildan offers a wider spectrum, including vibrant colors and heathers, with a more traditional fleece appearance. If you’re looking for a hoodie to customize or print on, Gildan’s smoother surface is a favorite among artists. For everyday wear, the EcoSmart’s softer drape might look more stylish straight off the rack.
Price is often the deciding factor, and both are wallet-friendly. Generally, the Hanes EcoSmart is priced slightly higher than Gildan, but often goes on sale. Gildan is consistently one of the cheapest quality hoodies on the market, making it an unbeatable value for bulk buys or tight budgets. Both are excellent for the price, but if you’re counting pennies, Gildan usually wins. However, the EcoSmart’s eco-friendly angle (it uses recycled polyester) and softer feel might justify the small price difference for some. To see the latest prices and compare more options, check out our best hoodies guide.
Both hoodies offer similar warmth, but Hanes EcoSmart feels slightly warmer due to its thicker, brushed fleece. Gildan is a bit thinner, making it more breathable for active wear.
Yes, both can be machine dried on low heat. However, to minimize shrinkage and maintain softness, it’s best to hang them dry. Gildan tends to shrink less than the EcoSmart, which may shrink slightly on the first wash if not careful.
Gildan runs true to size, while Hanes EcoSmart runs slightly large. If you prefer a fitted look, size down in the EcoSmart; if you want a relaxed fit, stick with your normal size.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.