Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: You need both if you do serious DIY or professional work. But if you must choose one, it depends on your primary task. A hammer drill is for drilling into masonry (brick, concrete, stone). An impact driver is for driving screws fast and with high torque, especially into wood. If you mostly hang shelves and assemble furniture, get an impact driver. If you plan to drill into concrete or brick, get a hammer drill. Many people eventually buy both, as they complement each other.
Hammer drills use a chuck that grips the bit tightly. They have a hammering action that pushes the bit forward and back while rotating, which helps pulverize masonry. You can turn off the hammer mode to use it as a regular drill. Impact drivers use a collet that accepts hex shank bits. They deliver rotational impacts, or bursts of high torque, when resistance is high. This makes them excellent for driving long screws without stripping or camming out.
Think of it this way: a hammer drill is a drill with a jackhammer feature. An impact driver is a screwdriver with a power assist. The hammer drill’s action is axial (forward/backward), while the impact driver’s action is radial (sideways force on the bit).
Hammer drills are rated by voltage (12V, 18V, 20V) and impact energy (in Joules or BPM, blows per minute). They excel at drilling holes. The chuck accepts round bits, which is essential for drill bits. Impact drivers are rated by voltage and Newton meters (Nm) of torque. They produce up to 3x more torque than a standard drill, but they only drive hex bits. They are not designed for drilling clean holes. You can use impact-rated drill bits with a hex shank, but they are less common and often less accurate.
For masonry, a hammer drill with SDS-Plus chuck (used with special bits) is the best. For wood, an impact driver with a hex bit is faster and less likely to strip screws. For metal, a regular drill with a variable speed is better, as hammer action is not needed and can damage bits.
Choose a hammer drill if you need to drill into concrete, brick, or stone. This includes tasks like mounting a TV bracket on a brick wall, installing anchors in a concrete floor, or drilling holes for wire through masonry. A hammer drill is also your go-to for drilling into wood or metal when you need a precise hole. You can turn off the hammer mode for these tasks.
If you are a homeowner who occasionally needs to hang a shelf on a stud, drill a hole for a door lock, or make pilot holes, a hammer drill is versatile. It can do everything a regular drill can do, plus masonry. Look for a model with variable speed, a clutch (to prevent stripping), and maybe a side handle for control on tough jobs. If you are considering buying one, check out this hammer drill buying guide for honest comparisons of top models.
Choose an impact driver if you spend a lot of time driving screws. This includes deck building, drywall installation, furniture assembly, and any project where you have dozens of screws. The impact driver’s high torque and quick bursts prevent you from stripping the screw head or burning out the motor. It is also more compact and lighter than most hammer drills, allowing you to work in tight spaces.
However, the impact driver is not for precision drilling. The hex collet only accepts bits with a 1/4 inch hex shank. You can buy hex shank drill bits, but they wobble slightly, making holes less accurate. Also, the impact action can damage delicate materials or over-tighten screws if you are not careful. It is best to use it for fastening, not drilling.
No, not really. You can use a hammer drill to drive screws, but it is slower and more likely to strip. You can use an impact driver to drill small holes in wood, but it is not ideal for larger bits or masonry. Some manufacturers have introduced impact drivers with a drill mode, but they still lack the chuck and precision of a true hammer drill. If you are on a tight budget and only do light DIY, a hammer drill might be the better all-rounder because it can do both drilling and driving, albeit poorly at driving. But if you do any serious woodwork, you will quickly want an impact driver.
When comparing hammer drills, look at: voltage (higher voltage usually means more power), chuck size (typically 1/2 inch), variable speed (for control), and BPM (blows per minute, higher is better for masonry). For impact drivers, look at: voltage, maximum torque (in inch-pounds or Nm), and IPM (impacts per minute). Higher torque means it can drive larger screws. Also consider battery compatibility if you are already in a brand ecosystem. Many people buy a combo kit with both tools, which is often more cost-effective than buying separately.
If you already have a regular drill, buy an impact driver as your next tool. If you have nothing, start with a hammer drill because it gives you the most functionality. But know that as you grow in DIY, you will eventually want both. The good news is many kits offer both, and the prices are reasonable. For specific recommendations on hammer drills, refer to the best hammer drills guide. It covers options for every budget. Remember, the best tool is the one that fits your immediate needs and feels comfortable in your hand.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.