Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The short answer: If you want a versatile, compact, and affordable juicer for everyday fruits and veggies, the Breville Juice Fountain Cold Plus is your best bet. If you juice large quantities, tough leafy greens, or whole fruits frequently, the Cold XL offers a bigger motor, a larger feed chute, and a wider pulp bin, but it costs more and takes up more counter space. Your choice ultimately depends on your juicing volume and budget.
Both juicers share Breville’s signature centrifugal design with a cold extraction system, but they differ in power, capacity, and convenience. The Cold Plus has a 850-watt motor, an 3-inch feed chute, and a 70-ounce pulp container. The Cold XL bumps up to a 1,200-watt motor, a 3.5-inch feed chute, and a 1.5-quart pulp bin. These upgrades translate into faster juicing, less prep, and fewer interruptions for emptying pulp.
The Cold Plus is no slouch; it can juice a glass of orange juice in about 5 seconds, thanks to its high-speed centrifugal action. However, the Cold XL’s more powerful motor handles whole apples, large carrots, and even fibrous greens like kale with less effort. If you often juice hard vegetables or leafy greens, the Cold XL’s extra power means less jamming and faster processing. For softer fruits like citrus and berries, the Cold Plus is perfectly adequate.
The Cold Plus’s 3-inch chute fits most whole fruits and vegetables, but you’ll need to chop larger items like whole pineapples or large beets. The Cold XL’s 3.5-inch chute is wider, allowing you to load entire fruits, which saves significant prep time. If you’re a busy person who wants to minimize slicing, the Cold XL is a clear winner. However, if you don’t mind a little chopping, the Cold Plus’s chute is still generous.
With a 70-ounce pulp container, the Cold Plus lets you juice for a while before needing to empty it. The Cold XL’s 1.5-quart bin holds more than 50% more pulp, which is ideal for big batches or continuous juicing. Cleanup is similar: both have dishwasher-safe parts, but the Cold XL’s larger bin is easier to handle when full. If you juice for a family or meal prep, the Cold XL’s larger capacity reduces interruptions.
Both machines feature Breville’s sturdy construction with a die-cast metal base and a polished finish. The Cold Plus is more compact and fits under standard upper cabinets, while the Cold XL is taller and bulkier. If counter space is at a premium, the Cold Plus is more practical. The Cold XL also has a slightly larger footprint and may require dedicated space. Both offer a 2-year warranty, with the Cold Plus typically priced lower, making it a better entry-level option.
Both use Breville’s Cold Extraction System, which spins at up to 13,000 RPM but minimizes heat buildup to preserve nutrients. The Cold XL’s more powerful motor spins faster, but it also generates a bit more heat. In our research, we found that both produce high-quality juice with comparable nutrient retention, though the Cold Plus’s lower speed may slightly favor delicate enzymes. That said, neither is a slow masticating juicer, so for maximum nutrient retention, you might consider other types. For everyday juicing, both are excellent.
If you juice in large quantities daily or love whole fruits without prep, yes. The larger motor, chute, and pulp bin make juicing faster and more convenient. If you juice occasionally or in small batches, the Cold Plus offers better value.
Yes, both can handle leafy greens, but the Cold XL’s higher power processes them more efficiently. For best results, roll leaves into a ball and alternate with a watery fruit like cucumber to push them through.
Both have dishwasher-safe components and a cleaning brush. The Cold Plus has fewer parts, making it slightly easier to clean. The Cold XL’s larger parts are still manageable but take up more sink space. For more juicing tips, check out our [best juicers guide](https://top10tierproducts.com/best-juicers/).
Choose the Breville Juice Fountain Cold Plus if you want a reliable, compact, and budget-friendly juicer for everyday use. Choose the Cold XL if you need high-volume juicing, minimal prep, and don’t mind paying more for extra power and capacity. Both are excellent choices; your decision should hinge on your juicing habits and kitchen space.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product mentioned on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, any ranking referenced here is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review.