overall
OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with Lid
9.5
Check price on Amazon → Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
After analyzing hundreds of owner reviews and verified specs, the top pick for most households is the OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with Lid. It combines a flexible silicone base, a tight-fitting lid to prevent freezer odors, and easy-release cubes.
| # | Product | Best for | Material | Capacity (cubes) | Lid Included | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with Lid | overall | Silicone | 18 cubes | Yes | Check Price |
| 2 | W&P Porter Ceramic Ice Bucket with Tray | style | Ceramic + Silicone | 18 cubes | Yes (tray only) | Check Price |
| 3 | Silicone Molds World Silicone Ice Ball Mold (2-Pack) | ice balls | Silicone | 2 ice balls per mold | No | Check Price |
| 4 | ONWA Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin (2-Pack) | value | Silicone + Plastic | 18 cubes per tray | Yes (lid and bin) | Check Price |
Why we picked it: The OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray with Lid is our top pick because it combines practical design with durability. The silicone base allows for effortless twisting to release cubes, while the lid prevents freezer burn and odor absorption. Owners consistently praise its sturdy feel and the fact that cubes don't stick. It's also dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
Perfect for everyday use, especially if you want odor-free cubes and easy release.
Not ideal if you need extra-large cubes or novelty shapes.
Key specs: Material: Silicone - Capacity: 18 cubes - Lid: Yes - Dimensions: 10.5 x 5.5 x 1.5 inches - Dishwasher safe: Yes
Why we picked it: The W&P Porter set combines a stylish ceramic bucket with a silicone ice tray that fits perfectly inside. The tray produces 18 cubes and the bucket keeps them cold for hours. Owners love the aesthetic and the fact that the tray is removable for easy filling. The double-wall insulation is a bonus for entertaining.
Great for those who want a stylish ice solution for parties or home bars.
Not for those on a budget or needing high volume.
Key specs: Material: Ceramic bucket, silicone tray - Capacity: 18 cubes - Lid: Yes (for bucket) - Dimensions: 6.5 x 6.5 x 7 inches - Dishwasher safe: Tray only
Why we picked it: This silicone mold produces perfect 2.5-inch ice balls that are a hit for cocktails and spirits. The two-pack gives you four balls at a time. Owners report that the balls come out smooth and clear if you use filtered water. The flexible silicone makes release simple, though freezing time is longer due to size.
Best for home bartenders who want impressive spherical ice for drinks.
Not for high-volume ice needs or small freezers.
Key specs: Material: Silicone - Capacity: 2 balls per mold - Lid: No - Ball diameter: 2.5 inches - BPA-free: Yes
Why we picked it: The ONWA set offers excellent value with two trays, lids, and a storage bin. The silicone trays are flexible for easy release, and the lids prevent spills and odors. Owners like the stackable design and the included bin for storing cubes. It's a budget-friendly option that performs well.
Perfect for families or anyone needing a complete ice solution on a budget.
Not for those wanting premium materials or large cubes.
Key specs: Material: Silicone trays, plastic bin - Capacity: 18 cubes per tray - Lid: Yes - Dimensions: 10 x 5 x 1.5 inches - BPA-free: Yes
Silicone is the most popular because it's flexible, easy to release cubes, and often dishwasher safe. Stainless steel freezes faster but is rigid. Plastic is cheap but can crack and absorb odors.
Use filtered or distilled water and freeze slowly. Some trays designed for clear ice use directional freezing. Boiling water twice before freezing can also reduce cloudiness.
Yes, most are made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone. Ensure the product is labeled as such. Silicone is non-toxic and heat-resistant.
Most silicone trays are dishwasher safe, but always check the manufacturer's instructions. Some may recommend top rack only.
Silicone is flexible and easy to release cubes, but can absorb odors if not covered. Stainless steel freezes fast but is rigid. Plastic is cheap but less durable. Choose based on your priorities: ease, speed, or cost.
Standard cubes fit most glasses, while jumbo cubes or balls melt slower and are great for spirits. Consider what you drink most often. Novelty shapes are fun but may be harder to release.
Lids prevent freezer odors from tainting your ice and make stacking easier. If you have a freezer with strong smells, a lid is essential. Otherwise, open trays are fine and often cheaper.
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Material Quality | The material affects durability, ease of release, and ice clarity. Silicone is the most versatile, but stainless steel offers faster freezing. Ensure it's BPA-free. |
| Ease of Release | Flexible silicone trays allow you to twist or pop out cubes easily. Rigid trays may require tapping or running under water. Look for non-stick surfaces. |
| Lid Design | A tight-fitting lid prevents odor absorption and spills. Some lids also allow stacking. Check that the lid seals well and is easy to remove. |
| Capacity and Batch Size | Consider how many cubes you need at once. Larger trays or multi-packs are better for parties. Smaller trays are fine for daily use. Balance with freezer space. |
Every product above was scored out of 10 on the same six-part rubric, then sorted into an S to C tier. We do not accept free units or payment for placement, and price or affiliate commission never factors into the score.
| Criterion | What we check | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Core performance | The numbers that define the category: capacity, power, resolution, battery life, speed or output, taken from manufacturer specs and cross-checked against independent test data where it exists. | High |
| Build & reliability | Materials, warranty length, brand track record, and how often the model shows up in long-term failure or return complaints. | High |
| Real-world usability | Weight, dimensions, noise level, setup difficulty and day-to-day friction, drawn from owner reviews and published measurements. | Medium |
| Running cost | Ongoing costs beyond the purchase: subscriptions, consumables, energy use or maintenance, where they apply to the category. | Medium |
| Owner feedback | Patterns across aggregated verified owner reviews: recurring praise, recurring complaints, and whether the experience matches the marketing. | Medium |
| Value | What you get relative to the rest of the field at a similar price band, not an absolute price judgment. | Medium |
Sources: manufacturer spec sheets and manuals, retailer listing data, aggregated verified owner reviews, and published independent test results where available for the category.
Honesty note: We have not hands-on tested every product on this page. Where we have not personally used a product, its ranking is based on verified specs, aggregated owner feedback, availability and editorial comparison rather than a hands-on review. Hands-on impressions, when included in a product entry above, are clearly written from direct use.
We don't accept free units or payment for placement. Our rankings combine verified manufacturer specifications, real owner feedback and availability, compared on one transparent S to C rubric.